Poetry
A friend and I spent an afternoon last week going around this one, and I have not stopped turning the shape of it over since. He called it the practical and the poetry, and I think the naming is better than most of what gets written about work and life.
The practical is easy to list. Homework, deadlines, the water tank, the EMI, the school fee, the thing on your list you have been avoiding for eleven days. The poetry is harder to say and easier to feel. It is the song you are actually in, the drummer you march to, the flow and the adventure, and the intuition that says this is the thing even when the spreadsheet has a different opinion.
We are raised on a very specific version of this in India. Practical means an engineering seat or a government job, and poetry means the thing you do after dinner that nobody is allowed to call work. My generation got told to finish the degree first and then do what we love, which is a sentence that quietly assumes the two never meet again.
Then there is the softer version, the one you hear in the spiritual circuit, that you should honour the poetry too, meet it halfway, find a balance. Fine advice and I have repeated it myself. The trouble is that halfway is still a compromise, and a compromise is a thing you can schedule.
Sometimes the answer is not a compromise at all. Sometimes the most practical thing you can do is something with no practical case behind it, which sounds like an oxymoron and is not, because the thing your head needs most is often the thing your calendar cannot justify. Terence McKenna put it as nature loving courage, that you make the commitment and nature responds by removing the impossible obstacles, and I have half a life of evidence for that and half against it. The times I quit a steady thing to build something, the obstacles did not vanish. They became mine to solve, which is different from impossible and better.
This is the point where the conversation usually goes metaphysical and I get off the bus 😬. The dream the impossible dream advice, the shamanic dance in the waterfall, the leap into the abyss which turns out to be a feather bed. I have jumped and it was a feather bed once and a hard floor the other time, and I would still rather have the floor than stay on the ledge.
The best line I know on this comes from a Julia Roberts movie of all places. She has spent a year fixing her life, the yoga and the breath work and the journaling and the medication, and she has finally found her balance. Then she falls in love, loses it completely, and ends the relationship because it is not practical. The shaman listens to all this and says that sometimes losing balance for love is part of living a balanced life.
I think that sentence is doing more work than the philosophy textbooks do with the word synthesis. Most of us treat balance as a state you achieve and then defend, when it behaves more like a walk, where you are always slightly falling and catching yourself, and standing still is how you actually fall over.
The zen people said the same thing shorter. Before enlightenment, chop wood, carry water. After enlightenment, chop wood, carry water. The poetry does not replace the chores, it just stops being their opposite, and that is the whole of what I understood that afternoon with my friend.
What I still cannot do is tell the two apart in advance. The poem and the waste of an afternoon look identical on a Tuesday, and the only test I have found is whether the thing leaves you with something to carry back to the woodpile. What was the last impractical thing that turned out to be the practical one for you? Post a comment, or tweet to me at @troysk704.